Does your butter actually need to sit in a butter dish if it's out on your counter? There's actually a good read it should.
Tupperware® Impressions Small Butter Dish – Tupperware CA
Melamine Butter Dish, Tableware, Dinnerware Sets
Butter Crock: This Is Why You Need One
Modern Butter Dish - Foter
Does Butter Need to Be Refrigerated?
Does Butter Go Bad?
The 5 Best Butter Dishes
What Exactly Is a Butter Bell — and Why You Need One
The 5 Best Butter Dishes
Melamine Butter Dish, Tableware, Dinnerware Sets
When You Should Use A Butter Dish Over A Butter Crock